Banging Noises, Odd Smells, or Soot Around Your Furnace? A Cracked Heat Exchanger Could Be Leaking Deadly Carbon Monoxide

Your furnace has one job in the winter: keep your home warm while safely venting harmful combustion gases outside. At the center of that process is the heat exchanger, a sealed metal chamber that separates the air you breathe from the gases created during combustion. If that metal chamber cracks, even slightly, it can allow carbon monoxide (CO) and other exhaust gases to mix with your indoor air. As Northeast Ohio’s expert provider of furnace and boiler services, we’re covering the warning signs of this invisible threat and how you can protect your home and family from carbon monoxide exposure.

The Warning Signs: Listen for the “Bang” and “Click”

Sounds are one of the most common cracked heat exchanger symptoms:

• Furnace banging noises: When your furnace turns on, the metal inside heats up and expands. But if the heat exchanger is cracked, the expansion and contraction aren’t even anymore. You may hear loud banging or popping right as the unit starts up.
• Clicking sounds: If you hear a distinct clicking sound after the blower shuts off, this may signal that the metal is cooling unevenly due to a fracture.

While not every noise means disaster, new or unusually sharp sounds during startup and shutdown are worth investigating.

Visual Red Flags: Soot, Corrosion, and Flame Color

If you notice soot around the furnace cabinet or inside the burner area, take it seriously. Soot around furnace components usually indicates incomplete combustion, which can happen when airflow or combustion is disrupted by a compromised heat exchanger.

You should also check the burner flame. A healthy furnace flame should be steady and blue. If you see a flickering yellow or orange flame, that’s a red flag. It can suggest improper combustion or gas mixing, both of which can be tied to a cracked exchanger. Rust, corrosion, or visible cracks on the metal surfaces are also signs that the system is aging or deteriorating.

Smelling the Danger: The “Formaldehyde” Odor

Carbon monoxide itself has no smell; that’s what makes it so dangerous. However, when a heat exchanger is damaged, other gases can escape along with it. Homeowners sometimes describe a furnace that smells like formaldehyde, ozone, or even a “dirty sock” odor when the heat kicks on. These strange furnace smells can be a warning that combustion gases are escaping somewhere they shouldn’t be.

Why This Isn’t a DIY Fix: The Necessity of Professional Testing

A cracked heat exchanger is a job for professional furnace repair, not a DIY project. That’s because this issue often isn’t visible to the naked eye. Technicians use specialized tools like combustion analyzers and infrared cameras to detect tiny fractures and measure unsafe gas levels. Attempting to patch or seal a crack yourself is extremely risky.

As Cleveland HVAC experts, the team at Verne & Ellsworth Hann understands how hard Ohio winters are on heating systems. During peak heating season, safety inspections are one of our top priorities for homes across Northeast Ohio.

Don’t Ignore the Signs – Act Immediately

A cracked heat exchanger is often considered a “red tag” situation, meaning the gas supply should be shut off immediately to prevent further operation. If you notice furnace banging noises, soot around your furnace, unusual odors, or possible carbon monoxide leak symptoms, check your CO detectors right away. Then, schedule a safety inspection with the team at Verne & Ellsworth Hann. We’ll perform a comprehensive inspection of your heating system to make sure your home and family stay safe.

Schedule a furnace safety inspection with our team today and protect your home from hidden carbon monoxide risks.

Furnace Heat Exchanger FAQs